For some context, you may want to read the following essays
- Ayya Sudhamma Therī: “From Lioness Roars to Purrs – A Review of The First Free Women by Matty Weingast” (10 min)
- Ven. Akaliko: “A Buddhist Literary Scandal; the Curious Case of The First Free Women” (36 min.)
- Bodhipaksa: “The First Free Women as Literary Fraud” (17 min.)
- An Tran: How a Poetry Collection Masquerading as Buddhist Scripture Nearly Duped the Literary World
- Kimberly Beek: The Importance of Genre: A Poetic Scandal in Contemporary Buddhist Literature
Actions you can take
Please read the article Actions you can take to get ideas of things you can to to correct the record on TFFW.
To learn more about the reaction to The First Free Women book and how to get involved:
- Public statements to and from Shambhala Publications
- Online spread of The First Free Women book.
- What is Shambhala’s Ethical Responsibility? Things to tell Shambhala.
- Timeline of events
And more background:
- Transcripts of author events.
- Quotations from the Buddha about the importance of scriptural accuracy
- Complete Therigatha bibliography
- FAQ if you are new to the Therigatha.
- Bibliography
- Online Spread. It’s useful to see how widely this book is being used as a real translation.
Public translations:
These translations appear in this article published by BCBS. or on the Shambhala Publications book page.
- 01.04 Tissā Therī [Tissa the Third(sic.)] (4) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Meaning
- 01.07 Another Dhīrā (7) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, IMSB Interview, Removal of Māra
- 02.03 A certain unknown bhikkhuni [Sumangala’s Mother] (23-24) 90% Fabrication, Sexualized
- 02.05 Cittā Therī [Chitta (sic.)] (27-28) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 02.07 Mittā [Another Mitta] (31-32) 90% Fabrication, BCBS Article, Removal of Rebirth
- 03.04 Dantikā Therī (48-50) Free Translation
- 03.05 Ubbirī Therī (51-53) 90% Fabrication, BCBS Article, Novel Meaning, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment
- 03.06 Sukkā Therī (54-56) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Māra
- 03.07 Selā Therī (57-59) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Māra, Removal of Sense Pleasure Danger
- 04.01 Bhaddā Kāpilānī (63-66) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 05.01 A certain unknown bhikkhunī (67-71) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Similar Narrative
- 05.04 Nandā Therī [Sundarīnandā] (82.86) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 06.5 Anopamā Therī (151-156) Anachronism, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment
- 06.6: Mahā Pajāpatī Gotamī (157-162) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 06.8 Vijayā (169-174) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Many Paths Fallacy, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative, Somewhat un-Buddhist
- 10.1 Kisāgotamī Therī (213-223) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative
- 13.2 Rohiṇī Therī (271-290) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 13.3 Cāpā Therī (291-311) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Meaning
All translations:
- 01.01 A certain unknown bhikkhuni (1) Translation
- 01.02 Muttā Therī (2) Added Weeping, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Meaning
- 01.03 Puṇṇā Therī (3) Free Translation
- 01.04 Tissā Therī [Tissa the Third(sic.)] (4) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Meaning
- 01.05 Another Tissā Therī (5) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Hell
- 01.06 Dhīrā (6) Anachronism, Complete Fabrication, Somewhat un-Buddhist
- 01.07 Another Dhīrā (7) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, IMSB Interview, Removal of Māra
- 01.08 Mittā Therī (8) 90% Fabrication
- 01.09 Bhadrā Therī (9) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Meaning
- 01.10 Upasamā Therī (10) Complete Fabrication, IMSB Interview, Removal of Māra
- 01.11 [Another] Muttā Therī (11) 50% fabrication, Sexualized
- 01.12 Dhammadinnā Therī (12) Complete Fabrication
- 01.13 Visakhā (13) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Buddha
- 01.14 Sumanā Therī Complete Fabrication, Removal of Meaning, Removal of Rebirth
- 01.15 Uttarā Therī (15) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Meaning
- 01.16 Sumanā, who went forth when old [Grandma Sumana] (16) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 01.17 Dhammā Therī (17) 50% fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative
- 01.18 Saṅghā Therī (18) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 02.01 Nandā [Abhirūpanandā] (19-20) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Meaning
- 02.02 Jentā (21-22) 90% Fabrication, Novel Meaning, Removal of Meaning
- 02.03 A certain unknown bhikkhuni [Sumangala’s Mother] (23-24) 90% Fabrication, Sexualized
- 02.04 Aḍḍhakāsī Therī (25-26) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 02.05 Cittā Therī [Chitta (sic.)] (27-28) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 02.06 Mettikā Therī 90% Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Similar Narrative
- 02.07 Mittā [Another Mitta] (31-32) 90% Fabrication, BCBS Article, Removal of Rebirth
- 02.08 Abhayamātā Therī [Abhaya’s Mother] (33-34) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Asubha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 02.09 Abhayā Theri (35-36) Complete Fabrication, Novel Meaning, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Meaning, Removal of Rebirth
- 02.10 Sāmā Therī (37-38) Complete Fabrication, Many Paths Fallacy, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 03.01 Another Sāmā Therī (39-41) 90% Fabrication, Adding Rebirth, Removal of Buddha
- 03.02 Uttamā (42-44) Complete Fabrication, IMSB Interview, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Removal of Teacher Nun
- 03.03 Another Uttamā Therī Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Removal of Teacher Nun
- 03.04 Dantikā Therī (48-50) Free Translation
- 03.05 Ubbirī Therī (51-53) 90% Fabrication, BCBS Article, Novel Meaning, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment
- 03.06 Sukkā Therī (54-56) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Māra
- 03.07 Selā Therī (57-59) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Māra, Removal of Sense Pleasure Danger
- 03.08 Somā Theri (60-62) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Sexualized
- 04.01 Bhaddā Kāpilānī (63-66) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 05.01 A certain unknown bhikkhunī (67-71) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Similar Narrative
- 05.02 Vimalā, the former courtesan (72-76)
- 05.03 Sīhā Therī (77-81)
- 05.04 Nandā Therī [Sundarīnandā] (82.86) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 05.05 Nanduttarā Therī (87-91) Added Weeping, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Sexualized
- 05.06 Mittakālī Therī (92-96) Added Weeping, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 05.07 Sakulā Theri (97-101) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative
- 05.08 Soṇā Therī (102-106)
- 05.09 Bhaddā Therī, the former Jain (107-111)
- 05.10 Patācārā Therī (112-116) Free Translation, Removal of Enlightenment
- 05.11 Thirty bhikkhunīs (117-121) 90% Fabrication, Novel Meaning, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 05.12 Candā Therī (122-126) Added Weeping, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Somewhat un-Buddhist
- 06.1 Pañcasatā Paṭācāra Therī (127-132) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment
- 06.2 Vāsiṭṭhī Therī (133-138) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative
- 06.3 Khemā Therī (139-144) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Asubha, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Similar Narrative
- 06.4 Sujātā Therī (145-150) 90% Fabrication, Broken Imagery, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 06.5 Anopamā Therī (151-156) Anachronism, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment
- 06.6: Mahā Pajāpatī Gotamī (157-162) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 06.7 Guttā Therī (163-168) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Hell, Removal of Māra, Removal of Meaning, Removal of Rebirth
- 06.8 Vijayā (169-174) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Many Paths Fallacy, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative, Somewhat un-Buddhist
- 07.1 Uttarā Therī (175-181) 90% Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Similar Narrative
- 07.2 Cālā Therī (182-187) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Māra, Removal of Meaning
- 07.3 Upacālā Therī (189-195) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Māra, Removal of Meaning
- 08.1 Sīsūpacālā Therī (196-203) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Māra, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative
- 09.1 Vaḍḍha’s mother (204-212) Complete Fabrication, Novel Meaning, Path Personification, Removal of Enlightenment, Similar Narrative
- 10.1 Kisāgotamī Therī (213-223) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning, Similar Narrative
- 11.1 Uppalavaṇṇā Therī (224-235) IMSB Interview
- 12.1 Puṇṇikā Therī (236-251) IMSB Interview
- 13.1 Ambapālī Therī (252-270) Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Similar Narrative
- 13.2 Rohiṇī Therī (271-290) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 13.3 Cāpā Therī (291-311) BCBS Article, Complete Fabrication, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Meaning
- 13.4 Sundarī Therī (312-337)
- 13.5 Subhā Therī, the smith’s daughter (338-365)
- 14.1 Subhā Jīvakambavanikā Therī (366-399) Similar Narrative
- 15.1 Isidāsī Therī (400-447) Huge Omission, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Meaning
- 16.1 Sumedhā Therī (448-512) Huge Omission, Removal of Buddha, Removal of Enlightenment, Removal of Rebirth, Similar Narrative